Outsider


I grew up in Northern Ireland and have been a teacher and lived in England, Ghana, Ireland, Northern Ireland, Malawi, Mexico, Colombia, The United Arab Emirates, Australia, Brunei Darussalam and Malaysia.

These are my memoirs which are arranged chronologically by year. Much is social commentary.

Aside from narrative recount, the style is often anecdotal, aphoristic and ironical. I try to soften the heavy social commentary with humour. Some friends have said I tend to 'rant' at times. I don't deny it! Perhaps it is the Irish in me. I apologise in advance then, if that is your impression too.

I do not intend to stereotype various nationalities but inevitably I will generalise for dramatic effect.

In a globalised multicultural world there is an urgent need to identify and face up to our national idiosyncracies and shortcomings. Nationalism has always seemed to me to be a bogus substitute for a genuine sense of connectedness and community. It is a highly dangerous concept when manipulated by politicians to get citizens to do things that are unpalatable to them-like going to war for instance.

If we don't begin to see ourselves as others perceive us - and not as we would like to see ourselves, then catastrophe looms.

I contend we can be comfortable with our heritage and still be able to criticize and even laugh at ourselves at the same time.


The two are not mutually exclusive.

Outsiders are in a unique position to show us our shortcomings because we simply cannot see them ourselves.

I believe that no culture has found the ideal 'solutions' to the challenges of life. Every culture I have lived in has both positive and disturbing characteristics.

In which cultures do people appear happiest? (notwithstanding natural and man-made disasters such as war and famine)

What question can be more profound than that?

The results may be surprising. In my experience, the happiest cultures were Ghana, Malawi, Mexico and Colombia. At the bottom of the list would be England, Ireland and Australia.

I think we need to learn from each other-not try to 'teach' each other...there is a big difference.

Please send me an E-mail if you would like to comment on anything.


Outsider


Outsider1952@gmail.com









Search This Blog

Retirement, Kota Kinabalu

Retirement, Kota Kinabalu
This is where I would like to be after I have robbed the bank

Winners and Losers

Winners and Losers
Debate 2008 Winners and Losers Editor at left.

Monday, January 4, 2016

2016 Student false beliefs D Generic Pleasure and the perfectibility of competence


Learning is not pleasurable



Language learning is perfectible



Many students arrive in Australia with the false belief that after what seems to them a ‘reasonable’ period of time in Australia taking a number of courses they will be able to speak with almost 100 percent performance like a native speaker-all they need to do is study hard , take courses with a good teacher.  This unrealistic view includes the perception that they will be to achieve a perfect accent and perfect dominion of the prosodic features of communication, perfect grammar,  perfect reading, listening comprehension and writing skills!

The teachers job here is to let them down gently. After the teacher has gained the confidence of the student they should be able to replace their disappointment at not being perfect with a more realistic acceptance of what they will be able to achieve linguistically. Only a caring teacher who is committed to the personal growth and development of his students will be able to do this. If the issue is not addressed  the student will  feel  let down and discouraged and may even give up on the language ‘project’ altogether. Such students will end up mixing with their own nationality. ( which is not one of the KPIS of the language programs or of the Australian government)

Again the problem here is indoctrination by the school system in the country of origin. Students internalize the mistaken idea that everything of value must be taught to them in a formal school setting.

Students who are let down gently by a caring teacher can still have a vigorous and productive language and cultural experience in Australia without expecting to have perfect language performance.

Because of the lifeless pedagogy and rigid didactic pedagogies employed in many educational institutions in their countries of origin students may often arrive in Australia with the idea that Learning is not pleasurable

This is a problem for the teacher because many of the activities in language teaching–even academic English language teaching are interactive and pleasurable for the learner . Games can be used for vocabulary development and speaking activities often involve pleasurable interchange with both teacher and fellow students. There is a danger that the student will undervalue these activities and see them as a waste of time.

The teacher must persist here and eventually the reluctant learner should  learn to ‘let this belief go’  enjoy themselves in class. I personally felt towards the end of my career that if the students hadn’t enjoyed themselves in my class  that particular  class as a failure. To connect learning with pleasure is to simply do the obvious. Children love learning but somehow learning in schools has become so politicised and manipulative that there is  often little or no pleasure in it at all-especially in the countries the learners come from.

Although I was adequate academically, I myself rarely enjoyed a class as a child or teenager. I became determined as a teacher that my classes would be enjoyable. In fact, this is one of the main reasons I changed from Science to English teaching half-way through my career. The methodology of language teaching is so much more enjoyable for me than that of science teaching ever was. Real world issues can be discussed. Videos can be watched, debates and discussions can be had. Games and interactive activities can be employed. This is very different from teaching science!

The content of science may be interesting but the methodology is much less flexible. Vive la difference!




No comments:

Post a Comment